Shows by day of week

• Sunday- 14
• Monday- 4
• Tuesday- 4
• Wednesday- 5
• Thursday- 7
• Friday- 19
• Saturday- 16

Shows by month

• January - 5
• February - 3
• March -
• April - 2
• May - 2
• June - 6
• July - 14
• August - 5
• September - 4
• October - 6
• November - 4
• December - 18

Shows by year

• 1998- 3
• 1999- 4
• 2000- 11
• 2001- 0
• 2002- 0
• 2003- 7
• 2004- 0
• 2009- 4
• 2010- 6
• 2011- 7
• 2012- 3
• 2013- 8
• 2014- 3
• 2015- 0
• 2016- 3
• 2017- 2
• 2018- 2
• 2019- 3
• 2020- 0
• 2021- 3
• 2022- 0
• 2023- 0
• 2024- 0

Most Frequently Played Dates

• 12/31- 7
• 12/28- 4
• 12/29- 3
• 7/12- 3
• 7/3- 3
• 1/1- 2
• 10/31- 2
• 12/30- 2
• 7/1- 2
• 7/10- 2
• 1/2- 1
• 1/3- 1
• 1/4- 1
• 10/29- 1
• 10/30- 1
• 10/7- 1
• 10/8- 1
• 11/1- 1
• 11/2- 1
• 11/27- 1
• 11/28- 1

Shows by States

• NY - 38 (55%)
• NJ - 12 (17%)
• VA - 3 (4%)
• IN - 3 (4%)
• FL - 3 (4%)
• CO - 2 (3%)
• NV - 2 (3%)
• PA - 2 (3%)
• CT - 2 (3%)
• MD - 2 (3%)

Shows by Time Zone

• Eastern - 65 (94%)
• Mountain - 2 (3%)
• Pacific - 2 (3%)
• Central - 0 (0%)

Shows by Cities

• New York, NY - 20 (29%)
• Atlantic City, NJ - 8 (12%)
• Uniondale, NY - 7 (10%)
• Watkins Glen, NY - 3 (4%)
• Albany, NY - 3 (4%)
• Hampton, VA - 3 (4%)
• Noblesville, IN - 3 (4%)
• Big Cypress, FL - 2 (3%)
• Las Vegas, NV - 2 (3%)
• Saratoga Springs, NY - 2 (3%)
• Hartford, CT - 2 (3%)
• Columbia, MD - 2 (3%)
• Holmdel, NJ - 2 (3%)
• Camden, NJ - 2 (3%)
• Commerce City, CO - 2 (3%)
• Wantagh, NY - 2 (3%)
• Hershey, PA - 1 (1%)
• Reading, PA - 1 (1%)
• Miami, FL - 1 (1%)
• Bethel, NY - 1 (1%)

Shows by Venues

• Madison Square Garden - 17 (25%)
• Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum - 7 (10%)
• Boardwalk Hall - 5 (7%)
• Atlantic City Beach - 3 (4%)
• Watkins Glen International - 3 (4%)
• Ruoff Music Center - 3 (4%)
• Pepsi Arena - 3 (4%)
• Hampton Coliseum - 3 (4%)
• Saratoga Performing Arts Center - 2 (3%)
• The Comcast Theatre - 2 (3%)
• Jones Beach Amphitheater - 2 (3%)
• Thomas & Mack Center - 2 (3%)
• Merriweather Post Pavilion - 2 (3%)
• Tweeter Center at the Waterfront - 2 (3%)
• Dick's Sporting Goods Park - 2 (3%)
• Big Cypress Seminole Indian Reservation - 2 (3%)
• Randall's Island - 2 (3%)
• Garden State Arts Center - 2 (3%)
• Radio City Music Hall - 1 (1%)
• Hersheypark Stadium - 1 (1%)
• Bethel Woods Center for the Arts - 1 (1%)
• American Airlines Arena - 1 (1%)
• Santander Arena - 1 (1%)

Hiatus Show Breakdown

• Before hiatus - 18 (26%)
• After hiatus - 51 (74%)

318 different songs have been played (32% of songs Phish have played).
The average number of songs per show is 22.2.
The average amount of times each song was played is 4.72.
There were 110 onetimers
1534 total songs have been played in the selected shows.

There were 59 two set shows
There were 9 three set shows
There were 1 four set shows
7 songs were in a four show rotation.
26 songs were in a five show rotation.

Total Times Played

Chalk Dust Torture - 20 (28%)
Run Like an Antelope - 20 (28%)
Ghost - 19 (27%)
Piper - 19 (27%)
Tweezer Reprise - 19 (27%)
Down with Disease - 18 (26%)
Possum - 18 (26%)
Backwards Down the Number Line - 17 (24%)
Bathtub Gin - 17 (24%)
Character Zero - 17 (24%)
Harry Hood - 17 (24%)
Wolfman's Brother - 17 (24%)
Back on the Train - 16 (23%)
Free - 16 (23%)
Sand - 16 (23%)
Tube - 16 (23%)
Tweezer - 16 (23%)
Bouncing Around the Room - 15 (21%)
Cavern - 15 (21%)
David Bowie - 15 (21%)
Slave to the Traffic Light - 15 (21%)
Birds of a Feather - 14 (20%)
Mike's Song - 14 (20%)
Twist - 14 (20%)
Weekapaug Groove - 14 (20%)
You Enjoy Myself - 14 (20%)
AC/DC Bag - 13 (18%)
Funky Bitch - 13 (18%)
Gotta Jibboo - 13 (18%)
Silent in the Morning - 13 (18%)
Wilson - 13 (18%)
46 Days - 12 (17%)
Heavy Things - 12 (17%)
Split Open and Melt - 12 (17%)
The Wedge - 12 (17%)
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 11 (15%)
Axilla - 11 (15%)
First Tube - 11 (15%)
Light - 11 (15%)
Reba - 11 (15%)
Runaway Jim - 11 (15%)
Simple - 11 (15%)
Suzy Greenberg - 11 (15%)
The Horse - 11 (15%)
The Moma Dance - 11 (15%)
Theme From the Bottom - 11 (15%)
Golgi Apparatus - 10 (14%)
Guyute - 10 (14%)
Halley's Comet - 10 (14%)
Julius - 10 (14%)
Limb By Limb - 10 (14%)
Ocelot - 10 (14%)
Rock and Roll - 10 (14%)
Sample in a Jar - 10 (14%)
Stash - 10 (14%)
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 9 (13%)
Fluffhead - 9 (13%)
Kill Devil Falls - 9 (13%)
Lawn Boy - 9 (13%)
Rift - 9 (13%)
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 9 (13%)
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 9 (13%)
Bug - 8 (11%)
Carini - 8 (11%)
Good Times Bad Times - 8 (11%)
I Am Hydrogen - 8 (11%)
Llama - 8 (11%)
Loving Cup - 8 (11%)
Maze - 8 (11%)
Meatstick - 8 (11%)
NICU - 8 (11%)
Roggae - 8 (11%)
Roses Are Free - 8 (11%)
Auld Lang Syne - 7 (10%)
Cars Trucks Buses - 7 (10%)
Crosseyed and Painless - 7 (10%)
Divided Sky - 7 (10%)
Horn - 7 (10%)
It's Ice - 7 (10%)
Makisupa Policeman - 7 (10%)
My Friend, My Friend - 7 (10%)
My Soul - 7 (10%)
Poor Heart - 7 (10%)
Prince Caspian - 7 (10%)
Sleeping Monkey - 7 (10%)
Sneakin' Sally Through the Alley - 7 (10%)
Walls of the Cave - 7 (10%)
When the Circus Comes - 7 (10%)
Ya Mar - 7 (10%)
Cities - 6 (8%)
Farmhouse - 6 (8%)
Golden Age - 6 (8%)
Halfway to the Moon - 6 (8%)
Martian Monster - 6 (8%)
Show of Life - 6 (8%)
Sparkle - 6 (8%)
The Squirming Coil - 6 (8%)
Twenty Years Later - 6 (8%)
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing - 5 (7%)
Dirt - 5 (7%)
Drowned - 5 (7%)
Fuego - 5 (7%)
Saw It Again - 5 (7%)
The Sloth - 5 (7%)
Walk Away - 5 (7%)
Water in the Sky - 5 (7%)
Waves - 5 (7%)
555 - 4 (5%)
Beauty of My Dreams - 4 (5%)
Camel Walk - 4 (5%)
Destiny Unbound - 4 (5%)
Foam - 4 (5%)
Frankie Says - 4 (5%)
Glide - 4 (5%)
Grind - 4 (5%)
Meat - 4 (5%)
More - 4 (5%)
My Mind's Got a Mind of its Own - 4 (5%)
Punch You in the Eye - 4 (5%)
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 4 (5%)
Rocky Top - 4 (5%)
Round Room - 4 (5%)
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 4 (5%)
Sugar Shack - 4 (5%)
Taste - 4 (5%)
What's the Use? - 4 (5%)
Wingsuit - 4 (5%)
A Day in the Life - 3 (4%)
Anything But Me - 3 (4%)
Billy Breathes - 3 (4%)
Catapult - 3 (4%)
Contact - 3 (4%)
Driver - 3 (4%)
Everything's Right - 3 (4%)
Fee - 3 (4%)
Fire - 3 (4%)
Frankenstein - 3 (4%)
Ginseng Sullivan - 3 (4%)
Guelah Papyrus - 3 (4%)
Gumbo - 3 (4%)
Ha Ha Ha - 3 (4%)
Hold Your Head Up - 3 (4%)
I Been Around - 3 (4%)
I Didn't Know - 3 (4%)
Jam - 3 (4%)
Mound - 3 (4%)
No Men In No Man's Land - 3 (4%)
No Quarter - 3 (4%)
Party Time - 3 (4%)
Pebbles and Marbles - 3 (4%)
Seven Below - 3 (4%)
Sing Monica - 3 (4%)
Sleep - 3 (4%)
Soul Shakedown Party - 3 (4%)
Steam - 3 (4%)
The Curtain - 3 (4%)
The Inlaw Josie Wales - 3 (4%)
The Lizards - 3 (4%)
The Star-Spangled Banner - 3 (4%)
Timber (Jerry the Mule) - 3 (4%)
Train Song - 3 (4%)
Waiting All Night - 3 (4%)
Waste - 3 (4%)
Yarmouth Road - 3 (4%)
After Midnight - 2 (2%)
Alaska - 2 (2%)
Albuquerque - 2 (2%)
Avenu Malkenu - 2 (2%)
Beauty of a Broken Heart - 2 (2%)
Big Black Furry Creature from Mars - 2 (2%)
Bittersweet Motel - 2 (2%)
Blaze On - 2 (2%)
Buried Alive - 2 (2%)
Colonel Forbin's Ascent - 2 (2%)
Corinna - 2 (2%)
Crazy Sometimes - 2 (2%)
Crowd Control - 2 (2%)
Devotion To a Dream - 2 (2%)
Dogs Stole Things - 2 (2%)
Don't Bogart That Joint - 2 (2%)
Fast Enough for You - 2 (2%)
Fly Famous Mockingbird - 2 (2%)
Friday - 2 (2%)
Joy - 2 (2%)
Life on Mars? - 2 (2%)
Manteca - 2 (2%)
McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters - 2 (2%)
Mellow Mood - 2 (2%)
Mexican Cousin - 2 (2%)
My Sweet One - 2 (2%)
Nellie Kane - 2 (2%)
Plasma - 2 (2%)
Rise/Come Together - 2 (2%)
Scent of a Mule - 2 (2%)
Set Your Soul Free - 2 (2%)
Steep - 2 (2%)
Swept Away - 2 (2%)
The Final Hurrah - 2 (2%)
The Line - 2 (2%)
The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday - 2 (2%)
The Mango Song - 2 (2%)
Time Loves a Hero - 2 (2%)
Two Versions of Me - 2 (2%)
Uncle Pen - 2 (2%)
Undermind - 2 (2%)
We Are Come to Outlive Our Brains - 2 (2%)
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 2 (2%)
Winterqueen - 2 (2%)
A Apolitical Blues - 1 (1%)
A Life Beyond The Dream - 1 (1%)
About to Run - 1 (1%)
All That You Dream - 1 (1%)
All of These Dreams - 1 (1%)
Alumni Blues - 1 (1%)
Amidst the Peals of Laughter - 1 (1%)
Ass Handed - 1 (1%)
Back at the Chicken Shack - 1 (1%)
Been Caught Stealing - 1 (1%)
Beneath a Sea of Stars Part 1 - 1 (1%)
Big Alligator - 1 (1%)
Big Balls - 1 (1%)
Bliss - 1 (1%)
Bold As Love - 1 (1%)
Breath and Burning - 1 (1%)
Brian and Robert - 1 (1%)
Buffalo Bill - 1 (1%)
Burn That Bridge - 1 (1%)
Chalk Dust Torture Reprise - 1 (1%)
Che Hun Ta Mo - 1 (1%)
Cool Amber and Mercury - 1 (1%)
Cool It Down - 1 (1%)
Crimes of the Mind - 1 (1%)
Day or Night - 1 (1%)
Dem Bones - 1 (1%)
Dinner and a Movie - 1 (1%)
Dixie Chicken - 1 (1%)
Drift While You're Sleeping - 1 (1%)
Fat Man in the Bathtub - 1 (1%)
Feats Don't Fail Me Now - 1 (1%)
Fly Like an Eagle - 1 (1%)
Fuck Your Face - 1 (1%)
Garden Party - 1 (1%)
Glide II - 1 (1%)
Golden Lady - 1 (1%)
Gone - 1 (1%)
Harpua - 1 (1%)
Heartbreaker - 1 (1%)
Highway to Hell - 1 (1%)
How Many People Are You - 1 (1%)
I Always Wanted It This Way - 1 (1%)
I Kissed a Girl - 1 (1%)
I Never Needed You Like This Before - 1 (1%)
Icculus - 1 (1%)
If I Could - 1 (1%)
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea - 1 (1%)
Iron Man - 1 (1%)
Izabella - 1 (1%)
Jesus Just Left Chicago - 1 (1%)
Jumpin' Jack Flash - 1 (1%)
Kung - 1 (1%)
Letter to Jimmy Page - 1 (1%)
Lifeboy - 1 (1%)
Light Up Or Leave Me Alone - 1 (1%)
Lonesome Cowboy Bill - 1 (1%)
Love You - 1 (1%)
Magilla - 1 (1%)
Mercenary Territory - 1 (1%)
Moby Dick - 1 (1%)
Monkey Man - 1 (1%)
Most Events Aren't Planned - 1 (1%)
Mountains in the Mist - 1 (1%)
Oh Atlanta - 1 (1%)
Old Folks Boogie - 1 (1%)
On Your Way Down - 1 (1%)
On the Road Again - 1 (1%)
Peaches en Regalia - 1 (1%)
Petrichor - 1 (1%)
Quadrophonic Toppling - 1 (1%)
Ramble On - 1 (1%)
Ride Captain Ride - 1 (1%)
Rocket in My Pocket - 1 (1%)
Ruby Waves - 1 (1%)
Sailin' Shoes - 1 (1%)
Sanity - 1 (1%)
Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. - 1 (1%)
Shade - 1 (1%)
Shine a Light - 1 (1%)
Snow - 1 (1%)
Spanish Moon - 1 (1%)
Spooky - 1 (1%)
Stairway to Heaven - 1 (1%)
Starman - 1 (1%)
Storage Jam - 1 (1%)
Susskind Hotel - 1 (1%)
Tela - 1 (1%)
Terrapin - 1 (1%)
Thank You - 1 (1%)
The Curtain With - 1 (1%)
The Dogs - 1 (1%)
The Landlady - 1 (1%)
The Old Home Place - 1 (1%)
Thunderhead - 1 (1%)
Tide Turns - 1 (1%)
Tomorrow's Song - 1 (1%)
Torn and Frayed - 1 (1%)
Tripe Face Boogie - 1 (1%)
Turtle in the Clouds - 1 (1%)
Tweezer Reprise Jam - 1 (1%)
Vultures - 1 (1%)
Walfredo - 1 (1%)
We're Not Gonna Take It - 1 (1%)
Weigh - 1 (1%)
Whole Lotta Love - 1 (1%)
Willin' - 1 (1%)
Windora Bug - 1 (1%)
Wombat - 1 (1%)
You Never Know - 1 (1%)
Your Pet Cat - 1 (1%)

First Set Openers

Llama - 5
AC/DC Bag - 4
Cars Trucks Buses - 4
Cavern - 2
Chalk Dust Torture - 2
Heavy Things - 2
Possum - 2
The Star-Spangled Banner - 2
Tube - 2
Wilson - 2
Alumni Blues - 1
Axilla - 1
Birds of a Feather - 1
Bouncing Around the Room - 1
Buried Alive - 1
Crowd Control - 1
David Bowie - 1
Dogs Stole Things - 1
Don't Bogart That Joint - 1
Down with Disease - 1
First Tube - 1
Fluffhead - 1
Frankenstein - 1
Funky Bitch - 1
Garden Party - 1
Ghost - 1
Gotta Jibboo - 1
Ha Ha Ha - 1
Kill Devil Falls - 1
Mellow Mood - 1
Mike's Song - 1
My Friend, My Friend - 1
My Soul - 1
NICU - 1
Piper - 1
Punch You in the Eye - 1
Run Like an Antelope - 1
Runaway Jim - 1
Sample in a Jar - 1
Sand - 1
Soul Shakedown Party - 1
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 1
The Landlady - 1
The Sloth - 1
The Wedge - 1
Theme From the Bottom - 1
Turtle in the Clouds - 1
Tweezer - 1
Walfredo - 1
Water in the Sky - 1
We Are Come to Outlive Our Brains - 1
Ya Mar - 1

First Set Closers

Run Like an Antelope - 9
Character Zero - 6
Walls of the Cave - 6
Split Open and Melt - 5
David Bowie - 4
Fluffhead - 3
Julius - 3
The Squirming Coil - 3
Bathtub Gin - 2
Cavern - 2
Possum - 2
Rock and Roll - 2
Suzy Greenberg - 2
You Enjoy Myself - 2
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing - 1
After Midnight - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Drift While You're Sleeping - 1
First Tube - 1
Free - 1
Golgi Apparatus - 1
Good Times Bad Times - 1
Izabella - 1
Light - 1
Monkey Man - 1
More - 1
My Soul - 1
Pebbles and Marbles - 1
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 1
Sand - 1
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 1
Weekapaug Groove - 1

Second Set Openers

Birds of a Feather - 6
Down with Disease - 6
Gotta Jibboo - 5
Carini - 3
Crosseyed and Painless - 3
Rock and Roll - 3
Sand - 3
Wilson - 3
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 2
Halley's Comet - 2
Punch You in the Eye - 2
Runaway Jim - 2
Tweezer - 2
Waves - 2
46 Days - 1
Backwards Down the Number Line - 1
Big Balls - 1
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Cool Amber and Mercury - 1
Drowned - 1
Everything's Right - 1
Fat Man in the Bathtub - 1
Glide - 1
Golden Age - 1
I Never Needed You Like This Before - 1
Jam - 1
Meatstick - 1
My Friend, My Friend - 1
No Men In No Man's Land - 1
Party Time - 1
Roses Are Free - 1
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 1
Set Your Soul Free - 1
Simple - 1
Tube - 1
Twist - 1
Wingsuit - 1
Wolfman's Brother - 1

Second Set Closers

Character Zero - 7
Slave to the Traffic Light - 6
You Enjoy Myself - 6
Harry Hood - 5
David Bowie - 4
Cavern - 3
Possum - 3
Run Like an Antelope - 3
Split Open and Melt - 3
Weekapaug Groove - 3
Good Times Bad Times - 2
Loving Cup - 2
Meatstick - 2
More - 2
Suzy Greenberg - 2
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 1
Bittersweet Motel - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Feats Don't Fail Me Now - 1
First Tube - 1
Ghost - 1
Grind - 1
Guyute - 1
I Been Around - 1
Martian Monster - 1
Rocky Top - 1
Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. - 1
The Star-Spangled Banner - 1
Tweezer Reprise - 1
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 1
You Never Know - 1

Third Set Openers

Cavern - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Character Zero - 1
Dem Bones - 1
Down with Disease - 1
Ghost - 1
Golden Age - 1
Meatstick - 1
Party Time - 1
Petrichor - 1

Third Set Closers

First Tube - 2
You Enjoy Myself - 2
A Day in the Life - 1
Grind - 1
Julius - 1
Lawn Boy - 1
Run Like an Antelope - 1
Weekapaug Groove - 1

Fourth Set Openers

Storage Jam - 1

Fourth Set Closers

Sleeping Monkey - 1

Encores

Tweezer Reprise - 15
Loving Cup - 5
First Tube - 4
Good Times Bad Times - 4
Show of Life - 4
Sleeping Monkey - 4
Fire - 3
Julius - 3
Slave to the Traffic Light - 3
A Day in the Life - 2
Backwards Down the Number Line - 2
Bouncing Around the Room - 2
Cavern - 2
Character Zero - 2
Contact - 2
Friday - 2
Grind - 2
Lawn Boy - 2
Mexican Cousin - 2
Rocky Top - 2
Run Like an Antelope - 2
A Life Beyond The Dream - 1
Been Caught Stealing - 1
Bold As Love - 1
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 1
Carini - 1
Chalk Dust Torture Reprise - 1
Crimes of the Mind - 1
Driver - 1
Farmhouse - 1
Fee - 1
Fluffhead - 1
Frankenstein - 1
Funky Bitch - 1
Golgi Apparatus - 1
Guyute - 1
Halley's Comet - 1
Harry Hood - 1
Highway to Hell - 1
I Am Hydrogen - 1
I Been Around - 1
Iron Man - 1
Joy - 1
Moby Dick - 1
On the Road Again - 1
Possum - 1
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 1
Reba - 1
Rock and Roll - 1
Roses Are Free - 1
Sample in a Jar - 1
Shine a Light - 1
Sneakin' Sally Through the Alley - 1
Suzy Greenberg - 1
The Inlaw Josie Wales - 1
The Squirming Coil - 1
Tube - 1
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 1
Waste - 1
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 1
Wilson - 1

10 20 30 40 50 most common songs that were not played in the band's history from your first year

Underplayed/Overplayed Songs since 1998

Expected versions is "percentage of shows the song was played in times number of shows seen" (eg if You Enjoy Myself were played in half of all shows and you have seen 20 shows, you would be "expected" to see 10 versions). These are the songs that you've seen the most above and below expectations. This section goes out to Amanda Wilson who inspired me to write it by seeing "Farmhouse" in each of her first 4 shows.

Underplayed

Overplayed

The 50% club

Longest Existing Gaps

Debut Count

You saw 68 song debuts
0.99 debuts per show.
The most frequently played song you have seen debuted is 46 Days (145 times).

Sort by Earliest debuted Most often played

Hiatus Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-hiatus songs that have not been seen since:

The Inlaw Josie Wales - 3
Albuquerque - 2
Bittersweet Motel - 2
Uncle Pen - 2
Back at the Chicken Shack - 1
Been Caught Stealing - 1
Big Alligator - 1
Buffalo Bill - 1
Chalk Dust Torture Reprise - 1
Che Hun Ta Mo - 1

Most frequently seen post-hiatus songs that were not seen before:

Backwards Down the Number Line - 17
46 Days - 12
The Wedge - 12
Light - 11
Ocelot - 10
Kill Devil Falls - 9
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 9
Divided Sky - 7
Walls of the Cave - 7
Golden Age - 6

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the hiatus are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post hiatus

Biggest increase post hiatus

Breakup Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-breakup songs that have not been seen since:

Frankie Says - 4
Catapult - 3
The Inlaw Josie Wales - 3
Albuquerque - 2
Bittersweet Motel - 2
Friday - 2
Mexican Cousin - 2
Uncle Pen - 2
All of These Dreams - 1
Back at the Chicken Shack - 1

Most frequently seen post-breakup songs that were not seen before:

Backwards Down the Number Line - 17
The Wedge - 12
Light - 11
Ocelot - 10
Kill Devil Falls - 9
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 9
Divided Sky - 7
Golden Age - 6
Halfway to the Moon - 6
Martian Monster - 6

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the breakup are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post breakup

Biggest increase post breakup

First/Last Time Seen