Shows by day of week

• Sunday- 12
• Monday- 5
• Tuesday- 8
• Wednesday- 10
• Thursday- 7
• Friday- 12
• Saturday- 20

Shows by month

• January - 1
• February - 2
• March - 1
• April -
• May -
• June - 13
• July - 25
• August - 13
• September - 2
• October - 3
• November - 6
• December - 8

Shows by year

• 1995- 1
• 1996- 2
• 1997- 10
• 1998- 8
• 1999- 7
• 2000- 8
• 2001- 0
• 2002- 0
• 2003- 13
• 2004- 3
• 2009- 4
• 2010- 7
• 2011- 3
• 2012- 2
• 2013- 4
• 2014- 2
• 2015- 0
• 2016- 0
• 2017- 0
• 2018- 0
• 2019- 0
• 2020- 0
• 2021- 0
• 2022- 0
• 2023- 0
• 2024- 0

Most Frequently Played Dates

• 12/30- 2
• 6/13- 2
• 6/23- 2
• 7/14- 2
• 7/15- 2
• 7/26- 2
• 7/27- 2
• 7/29- 2
• 7/31- 2
• 1/2- 1
• 10/29- 1
• 10/30- 1
• 10/31- 1
• 11/14- 1
• 11/15- 1
• 11/19- 1
• 11/6- 1
• 11/7- 1
• 11/8- 1
• 12/27- 1
• 12/28- 1

Shows by States

• IN - 10 (14%)
• OH - 8 (11%)
• MD - 7 (9%)
• WI - 6 (8%)
• MO - 6 (8%)
• NY - 6 (8%)
• NJ - 6 (8%)
• PA - 5 (7%)
• FL - 4 (5%)
• IL - 4 (5%)
• ME - 3 (4%)
• VA - 2 (3%)
• NC - 2 (3%)
• KS - 2 (3%)
• MA - 1 (1%)
• GA - 1 (1%)
• TN - 1 (1%)

Shows by Time Zone

• Eastern - 55 (74%)
• Central - 19 (26%)
• Mountain - 0 (0%)
• Pacific - 0 (0%)

Shows by Cities

• Noblesville, IN - 10 (14%)
• Columbia, MD - 7 (9%)
• East Troy, WI - 5 (7%)
• Cincinnati, OH - 4 (5%)
• Burgettstown, PA - 4 (5%)
• Columbus, OH - 4 (5%)
• Miami, FL - 4 (5%)
• Atlantic City, NJ - 3 (4%)
• St. Louis, MO - 3 (4%)
• Maryland Heights, MO - 3 (4%)
• Camden, NJ - 3 (4%)
• Albany, NY - 2 (3%)
• Bonner Springs, KS - 2 (3%)
• Limestone, ME - 2 (3%)
• Champaign, IL - 2 (3%)
• Hershey, PA - 1 (1%)
• Bangor, ME - 1 (1%)
• Tinley Park, IL - 1 (1%)
• Raleigh, NC - 1 (1%)
• Greensboro, NC - 1 (1%)
• Darien Center, NY - 1 (1%)
• Saratoga Springs, NY - 1 (1%)
• Worcester, MA - 1 (1%)
• Antioch, TN - 1 (1%)
• New York, NY - 1 (1%)
• Hampton, VA - 1 (1%)
• Atlanta, GA - 1 (1%)
• Madison, WI - 1 (1%)
• Charlottesville, VA - 1 (1%)
• Chicago, IL - 1 (1%)
• Canandaigua, NY - 1 (1%)

Shows by Venues

• Ruoff Music Center - 10 (14%)
• Merriweather Post Pavilion - 7 (9%)
• Alpine Valley Music Theatre - 5 (7%)
• Polaris Amphitheater - 4 (5%)
• American Airlines Arena - 4 (5%)
• U.S. Bank Arena - 4 (5%)
• Post-Gazette Pavilion at Star Lake - 4 (5%)
• Tweeter Center at the Waterfront - 3 (4%)
• Riverport Amphitheater - 3 (4%)
• University of Illinois - 3 (4%)
• Boardwalk Hall - 3 (4%)
• Loring Commerce Centre - 2 (3%)
• Verizon Wireless Amphitheater Kansas City - 2 (3%)
• Pepsi Arena - 2 (3%)
• Saratoga Performing Arts Center - 1 (1%)
• Hersheypark Stadium - 1 (1%)
• Madison Square Garden - 1 (1%)
• HiFi Buys Amphitheatre - 1 (1%)
• John Paul Jones Arena - 1 (1%)
• Worcester Centrum Centre - 1 (1%)
• Greensboro Coliseum - 1 (1%)
• Hampton Coliseum - 1 (1%)
• ALLTEL Pavilion - 1 (1%)
• World Music Theatre - 1 (1%)
• Kohl Center - 1 (1%)
• The Fox Theatre - 1 (1%)
• Darling's Waterfront Pavilion - 1 (1%)
• Starwood Amphitheatre - 1 (1%)
• Darien Lake Performing Arts Center - 1 (1%)
• Finger Lakes Performing Arts Center - 1 (1%)
• Saint Louis University - 1 (1%)
• Kiel Center - 1 (1%)

Hiatus Show Breakdown

• Before hiatus - 36 (49%)
• After hiatus - 38 (51%)

306 different songs have been played (30% of songs Phish have played).
The average number of songs per show is 20.1.
The average amount of times each song was played is 4.74.
There were 110 onetimers
1491 total songs have been played in the selected shows.

There were 70 two set shows
There were 4 three set shows
7 songs were in a four show rotation.
24 songs were in a five show rotation.

Total Times Played

Run Like an Antelope - 22 (29%)
Chalk Dust Torture - 21 (28%)
Piper - 20 (27%)
You Enjoy Myself - 20 (27%)
David Bowie - 19 (25%)
Down with Disease - 19 (25%)
Harry Hood - 19 (25%)
Bathtub Gin - 18 (24%)
Bouncing Around the Room - 18 (24%)
Character Zero - 18 (24%)
Wilson - 17 (22%)
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 16 (21%)
Cavern - 16 (21%)
Free - 16 (21%)
Funky Bitch - 16 (21%)
Loving Cup - 16 (21%)
Guyute - 15 (20%)
Julius - 15 (20%)
Mike's Song - 15 (20%)
Possum - 15 (20%)
Sample in a Jar - 15 (20%)
Tweezer - 15 (20%)
Weekapaug Groove - 15 (20%)
Wolfman's Brother - 15 (20%)
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 14 (18%)
Golgi Apparatus - 14 (18%)
Limb By Limb - 14 (18%)
NICU - 14 (18%)
Stash - 14 (18%)
Tweezer Reprise - 14 (18%)
Birds of a Feather - 13 (17%)
Divided Sky - 13 (17%)
Ghost - 13 (17%)
Theme From the Bottom - 13 (17%)
Tube - 13 (17%)
Prince Caspian - 12 (16%)
Simple - 12 (16%)
Taste - 12 (16%)
The Moma Dance - 12 (16%)
Maze - 11 (14%)
Runaway Jim - 11 (14%)
Back on the Train - 10 (13%)
Hold Your Head Up - 10 (13%)
Makisupa Policeman - 10 (13%)
Punch You in the Eye - 10 (13%)
Reba - 10 (13%)
Slave to the Traffic Light - 10 (13%)
The Squirming Coil - 10 (13%)
Twist - 10 (13%)
Ya Mar - 10 (13%)
Gotta Jibboo - 9 (12%)
My Soul - 9 (12%)
Split Open and Melt - 9 (12%)
The Wedge - 9 (12%)
Water in the Sky - 9 (12%)
AC/DC Bag - 8 (10%)
Cities - 8 (10%)
Dirt - 8 (10%)
Farmhouse - 8 (10%)
Fluffhead - 8 (10%)
Foam - 8 (10%)
Halley's Comet - 8 (10%)
It's Ice - 8 (10%)
Jam - 8 (10%)
My Friend, My Friend - 8 (10%)
Sand - 8 (10%)
Scent of a Mule - 8 (10%)
Silent in the Morning - 8 (10%)
Sparkle - 8 (10%)
Suzy Greenberg - 8 (10%)
46 Days - 7 (9%)
Axilla - 7 (9%)
Beauty of My Dreams - 7 (9%)
Camel Walk - 7 (9%)
Cars Trucks Buses - 7 (9%)
First Tube - 7 (9%)
Gumbo - 7 (9%)
Llama - 7 (9%)
The Horse - 7 (9%)
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 7 (9%)
Waste - 7 (9%)
Frankenstein - 6 (8%)
Heavy Things - 6 (8%)
Light - 6 (8%)
Rock and Roll - 6 (8%)
Roggae - 6 (8%)
Roses Are Free - 6 (8%)
Timber (Jerry the Mule) - 6 (8%)
Vultures - 6 (8%)
Backwards Down the Number Line - 5 (6%)
Billy Breathes - 5 (6%)
Brian and Robert - 5 (6%)
Crosseyed and Painless - 5 (6%)
Ginseng Sullivan - 5 (6%)
Good Times Bad Times - 5 (6%)
Kill Devil Falls - 5 (6%)
Lawn Boy - 5 (6%)
Mountains in the Mist - 5 (6%)
Ocelot - 5 (6%)
Poor Heart - 5 (6%)
Rocky Top - 5 (6%)
Seven Below - 5 (6%)
The Lizards - 5 (6%)
The Sloth - 5 (6%)
Walk Away - 5 (6%)
When the Circus Comes - 5 (6%)
Avenu Malkenu - 4 (5%)
Bug - 4 (5%)
Contact - 4 (5%)
Fee - 4 (5%)
Fire - 4 (5%)
Frankie Says - 4 (5%)
Friday - 4 (5%)
Horn - 4 (5%)
I Am Hydrogen - 4 (5%)
McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters - 4 (5%)
Meatstick - 4 (5%)
My Mind's Got a Mind of its Own - 4 (5%)
Rift - 4 (5%)
Saw It Again - 4 (5%)
Sleeping Monkey - 4 (5%)
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 4 (5%)
Strange Design - 4 (5%)
The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday - 4 (5%)
The Mango Song - 4 (5%)
Train Song - 4 (5%)
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 4 (5%)
Alaska - 3 (4%)
Bittersweet Motel - 3 (4%)
Bold As Love - 3 (4%)
Buried Alive - 3 (4%)
Dogs Stole Things - 3 (4%)
Driver - 3 (4%)
Drowned - 3 (4%)
Fikus - 3 (4%)
Glide - 3 (4%)
Guelah Papyrus - 3 (4%)
Ha Ha Ha - 3 (4%)
Hello My Baby - 3 (4%)
I Didn't Know - 3 (4%)
Mound - 3 (4%)
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 3 (4%)
Steep - 3 (4%)
Swept Away - 3 (4%)
Tela - 3 (4%)
The Curtain - 3 (4%)
The Curtain With - 3 (4%)
The Star-Spangled Banner - 3 (4%)
Walls of the Cave - 3 (4%)
Waves - 3 (4%)
Weigh - 3 (4%)
555 - 2 (2%)
Access Me - 2 (2%)
Albuquerque - 2 (2%)
Anything But Me - 2 (2%)
Army of One - 2 (2%)
Back at the Chicken Shack - 2 (2%)
Big Black Furry Creature from Mars - 2 (2%)
Bike - 2 (2%)
Brother - 2 (2%)
Buffalo Bill - 2 (2%)
Carolina - 2 (2%)
Catapult - 2 (2%)
Cool It Down - 2 (2%)
Daniel Saw the Stone - 2 (2%)
Esther - 2 (2%)
Fast Enough for You - 2 (2%)
Fat Man in the Bathtub - 2 (2%)
Fuego - 2 (2%)
Golden Age - 2 (2%)
Halfway to the Moon - 2 (2%)
Harpua - 2 (2%)
Izabella - 2 (2%)
Lifeboy - 2 (2%)
Lonesome Cowboy Bill - 2 (2%)
Meat - 2 (2%)
Mellow Mood - 2 (2%)
Mexican Cousin - 2 (2%)
My Left Toe - 2 (2%)
On Your Way Down - 2 (2%)
Party Time - 2 (2%)
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 2 (2%)
Ramble On - 2 (2%)
Show of Life - 2 (2%)
Sleep - 2 (2%)
Sneakin' Sally Through the Alley - 2 (2%)
Steam - 2 (2%)
Sweet Adeline - 2 (2%)
Terrapin - 2 (2%)
Thunderhead - 2 (2%)
Time Turns Elastic - 2 (2%)
Twenty Years Later - 2 (2%)
Uncle Pen - 2 (2%)
Undermind - 2 (2%)
What's the Use? - 2 (2%)
Yarmouth Road - 2 (2%)
A Apolitical Blues - 1 (1%)
Acoustic Army - 1 (1%)
Ain't Love Funny - 1 (1%)
All That You Dream - 1 (1%)
All Things Reconsidered - 1 (1%)
All of These Dreams - 1 (1%)
Alumni Blues - 1 (1%)
Amoreena - 1 (1%)
Architect - 1 (1%)
Art Jam - 1 (1%)
Auld Lang Syne - 1 (1%)
Axilla (Part II) - 1 (1%)
Beauty of a Broken Heart - 1 (1%)
Been Caught Stealing - 1 (1%)
Bye Bye Foot - 1 (1%)
Carini - 1 (1%)
Chalk Dust Torture Reprise - 1 (1%)
Colonel Forbin's Ascent - 1 (1%)
Corinna - 1 (1%)
Crossroads - 1 (1%)
Crowd Control - 1 (1%)
Day or Night - 1 (1%)
Destiny Unbound - 1 (1%)
Digital Delay Loop Jam - 1 (1%)
Discern - 1 (1%)
Dixie Chicken - 1 (1%)
Dog Faced Boy - 1 (1%)
Dog Log - 1 (1%)
Doin' My Time - 1 (1%)
Don't Bogart That Joint - 1 (1%)
Emotional Rescue - 1 (1%)
Energy - 1 (1%)
Feats Don't Fail Me Now - 1 (1%)
Feel the Heat - 1 (1%)
Fooled Around and Fell in Love - 1 (1%)
Grind - 1 (1%)
Happy Birthday to You - 1 (1%)
Heartbreaker - 1 (1%)
Hoochie Coochie Man - 1 (1%)
I Been Around - 1 (1%)
I Get a Kick Out of You - 1 (1%)
If I Could - 1 (1%)
If You Need a Fool - 1 (1%)
Iron Man - 1 (1%)
Jennifer Dances - 1 (1%)
Jesus Just Left Chicago - 1 (1%)
Joy - 1 (1%)
Jumpin' Jack Flash - 1 (1%)
Jungle Boogie - 1 (1%)
Kung - 1 (1%)
L.A. Woman - 1 (1%)
Lengthwise - 1 (1%)
Let Me Lie - 1 (1%)
Light Up Or Leave Me Alone - 1 (1%)
Love Me - 1 (1%)
Love You - 1 (1%)
Magilla - 1 (1%)
Mean Mr. Mustard - 1 (1%)
Mercenary Territory - 1 (1%)
Merry Pranksters Jam - 1 (1%)
Messin' with The Kid - 1 (1%)
Moby Dick - 1 (1%)
My Sweet One - 1 (1%)
Nellie Kane - 1 (1%)
Nothing - 1 (1%)
Oh Atlanta - 1 (1%)
Oh! Sweet Nuthin' - 1 (1%)
Old Folks Boogie - 1 (1%)
P-Funk Medley - 1 (1%)
Peaches en Regalia - 1 (1%)
Pebbles and Marbles - 1 (1%)
Proud Mary - 1 (1%)
Purple Rain - 1 (1%)
Rock A William - 1 (1%)
Rocket in My Pocket - 1 (1%)
Rotation Jam - 1 (1%)
Round Room - 1 (1%)
Sailin' Shoes - 1 (1%)
Sanity - 1 (1%)
Secret Smile - 1 (1%)
Sexual Healing - 1 (1%)
Shafty - 1 (1%)
Shine a Light - 1 (1%)
So Lonely - 1 (1%)
Something - 1 (1%)
Spanish Moon - 1 (1%)
Spock's Brain - 1 (1%)
Spooky - 1 (1%)
Stairway to Heaven - 1 (1%)
Sugar Shack - 1 (1%)
Sweet Virginia - 1 (1%)
Thank You - 1 (1%)
The Happy Whip and Dung Song - 1 (1%)
The Inlaw Josie Wales - 1 (1%)
The Old Home Place - 1 (1%)
Time Loves a Hero - 1 (1%)
Torn and Frayed - 1 (1%)
Tripe Face Boogie - 1 (1%)
Waiting All Night - 1 (1%)
Walfredo - 1 (1%)
What Things Seem - 1 (1%)
Whipping Post - 1 (1%)
Whole Lotta Love - 1 (1%)
Willin' - 1 (1%)
Windora Bug - 1 (1%)
Wingsuit - 1 (1%)
Wombat - 1 (1%)
Woodstock - 1 (1%)
You Ain't Goin' Nowhere - 1 (1%)
You Better Believe It Baby - 1 (1%)

First Set Openers

Wilson - 5
Kill Devil Falls - 4
Bathtub Gin - 3
My Friend, My Friend - 3
Possum - 3
Punch You in the Eye - 3
Runaway Jim - 3
Ya Mar - 3
AC/DC Bag - 2
Buried Alive - 2
Cars Trucks Buses - 2
Chalk Dust Torture - 2
Daniel Saw the Stone - 2
Funky Bitch - 2
Llama - 2
Makisupa Policeman - 2
Sample in a Jar - 2
Access Me - 1
Amoreena - 1
Cities - 1
Crowd Control - 1
David Bowie - 1
Emotional Rescue - 1
Farmhouse - 1
Fee - 1
First Tube - 1
Frankenstein - 1
Golgi Apparatus - 1
Gotta Jibboo - 1
Guyute - 1
Heavy Things - 1
Julius - 1
Loving Cup - 1
Meat - 1
Mellow Mood - 1
My Soul - 1
NICU - 1
Piper - 1
Ramble On - 1
Rocky Top - 1
Roggae - 1
The Sloth - 1
The Star-Spangled Banner - 1
The Wedge - 1
Theme From the Bottom - 1
Walfredo - 1

First Set Closers

Run Like an Antelope - 9
Character Zero - 8
Cavern - 4
David Bowie - 4
Golgi Apparatus - 4
Split Open and Melt - 4
The Squirming Coil - 3
You Enjoy Myself - 3
Birds of a Feather - 2
Funky Bitch - 2
Julius - 2
Possum - 2
Sample in a Jar - 2
Stash - 2
Taste - 2
Weekapaug Groove - 2
46 Days - 1
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 1
Bold As Love - 1
Carolina - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Crossroads - 1
Harry Hood - 1
I Didn't Know - 1
Llama - 1
Loving Cup - 1
Poor Heart - 1
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 1
Rock and Roll - 1
Slave to the Traffic Light - 1
Sweet Adeline - 1
The Curtain With - 1
Time Turns Elastic - 1
Tube - 1
Tweezer Reprise - 1

Second Set Openers

Down with Disease - 8
Birds of a Feather - 4
Gotta Jibboo - 4
Tube - 4
Tweezer - 4
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 3
Mike's Song - 3
Piper - 3
Wilson - 3
Wolfman's Brother - 3
Chalk Dust Torture - 2
David Bowie - 2
Ghost - 2
Golden Age - 2
Halley's Comet - 2
Makisupa Policeman - 2
Rock and Roll - 2
Runaway Jim - 2
46 Days - 1
AC/DC Bag - 1
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 1
Buried Alive - 1
Cities - 1
Crosseyed and Painless - 1
Drowned - 1
Energy - 1
Fat Man in the Bathtub - 1
Heavy Things - 1
Party Time - 1
Possum - 1
Punch You in the Eye - 1
Stash - 1
The Curtain - 1
The Squirming Coil - 1
The Wedge - 1
Timber (Jerry the Mule) - 1
Twist - 1

Second Set Closers

You Enjoy Myself - 10
Harry Hood - 6
Cavern - 5
Run Like an Antelope - 5
Weekapaug Groove - 5
Character Zero - 4
David Bowie - 4
Chalk Dust Torture - 3
Loving Cup - 3
Fire - 2
Frankenstein - 2
Good Times Bad Times - 2
Slave to the Traffic Light - 2
Suzy Greenberg - 2
Taste - 2
Walls of the Cave - 2
Bug - 1
Carolina - 1
Down with Disease - 1
Farmhouse - 1
Feats Don't Fail Me Now - 1
Fluffhead - 1
Golgi Apparatus - 1
Hello My Baby - 1
I Been Around - 1
Joy - 1
Julius - 1
Meatstick - 1
Possum - 1
Split Open and Melt - 1
Stash - 1

Third Set Openers

Buffalo Bill - 1
Down with Disease - 1
Halley's Comet - 1
Jungle Boogie - 1

Third Set Closers

Funky Bitch - 1
Prince Caspian - 1
Run Like an Antelope - 1
You Enjoy Myself - 1

Encores

Tweezer Reprise - 13
Loving Cup - 9
Julius - 5
The Squirming Coil - 5
Waste - 4
Bouncing Around the Room - 3
Character Zero - 3
First Tube - 3
Harry Hood - 3
Rocky Top - 3
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 3
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 3
Bittersweet Motel - 2
Bold As Love - 2
Camel Walk - 2
Contact - 2
Fire - 2
Frankenstein - 2
Good Times Bad Times - 2
Guyute - 2
Hello My Baby - 2
Hold Your Head Up - 2
Possum - 2
Run Like an Antelope - 2
Sleeping Monkey - 2
Suzy Greenberg - 2
Theme From the Bottom - 2
When the Circus Comes - 2
Alumni Blues - 1
Been Caught Stealing - 1
Bike - 1
Birds of a Feather - 1
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 1
Cavern - 1
Chalk Dust Torture Reprise - 1
Driver - 1
Farmhouse - 1
Funky Bitch - 1
Glide - 1
Golgi Apparatus - 1
Grind - 1
Hoochie Coochie Man - 1
Makisupa Policeman - 1
McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters - 1
Messin' with The Kid - 1
Mexican Cousin - 1
Moby Dick - 1
Proud Mary - 1
Punch You in the Eye - 1
Sample in a Jar - 1
Sanity - 1
Secret Smile - 1
Shine a Light - 1
Show of Life - 1
Slave to the Traffic Light - 1
So Lonely - 1
Sweet Adeline - 1
The Inlaw Josie Wales - 1
The Lizards - 1
The Star-Spangled Banner - 1
Woodstock - 1
You Enjoy Myself - 1

10 20 30 40 50 most common songs that were not played in the band's history from your first year

Underplayed/Overplayed Songs since 1995

Expected versions is "percentage of shows the song was played in times number of shows seen" (eg if You Enjoy Myself were played in half of all shows and you have seen 20 shows, you would be "expected" to see 10 versions). These are the songs that you've seen the most above and below expectations. This section goes out to Amanda Wilson who inspired me to write it by seeing "Farmhouse" in each of her first 4 shows.

Underplayed

Overplayed

The 50% club

Longest Existing Gaps

Debut Count

You saw 53 song debuts
0.72 debuts per show.
The most frequently played song you have seen debuted is Back on the Train (158 times).

Sort by Earliest debuted Most often played

Hiatus Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-hiatus songs that have not been seen since:

Beauty of My Dreams - 7
Billy Breathes - 5
Avenu Malkenu - 4
The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday - 4
Fikus - 3
Glide - 3
Back at the Chicken Shack - 2
Buffalo Bill - 2
Izabella - 2
Meat - 2

Most frequently seen post-hiatus songs that were not seen before:

46 Days - 7
Light - 6
Backwards Down the Number Line - 5
Kill Devil Falls - 5
Ocelot - 5
Seven Below - 5
The Sloth - 5
Friday - 4
I Am Hydrogen - 4
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 4

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the hiatus are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post hiatus

Biggest increase post hiatus

Breakup Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-breakup songs that have not been seen since:

Water in the Sky - 9
Dirt - 8
Beauty of My Dreams - 7
Cars Trucks Buses - 7
Llama - 7
Billy Breathes - 5
Lawn Boy - 5
Poor Heart - 5
Avenu Malkenu - 4
Bug - 4

Most frequently seen post-breakup songs that were not seen before:

Light - 6
Backwards Down the Number Line - 5
Kill Devil Falls - 5
Ocelot - 5
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 4
Alaska - 3
Bold As Love - 3
Ha Ha Ha - 3
555 - 2
Big Black Furry Creature from Mars - 2

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the breakup are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post breakup

Biggest increase post breakup

First/Last Time Seen